When you pick up a tin of sardines, check three things: what the fish is packed in, whether you're getting whole fish or fillets, and where it was caught and canned. Get those right and you'll like what's inside. Below is how to read each one on the label, then every sardine tin and jar on our shelves at the moment, side by side.
If you're wondering why sardines are suddenly everywhere, our tinned fish guide covers the trend. This one is for standing at the shelf trying to choose.
Why choosing got harder this year
Sardines had a big 2026. A social media trend called "sardinemaxxing" emptied shelves around the country, SBS News reported, with some influencers calling the fish "Botox on a fork". That last bit goes well beyond the evidence. The more useful point in the same report is that much of the tinned sardines sold in Australia is imported, so it can be hard to tell where a can came from or how the fish was caught. The label is your best guide.
What to look for on the tin
1. What they're packed in
Olive oil gives a soft, rich fish, and the oil is good enough to cook with or dress a salad. Extra virgin olive oil tastes fruitier than refined olive oil, and some brands also use sunflower oil. Water or brine gives a plainer fish that disappears into a pasta sauce or fishcakes. Tomato, lemon or chilli sauces turn the tin into a meal on toast.
The ingredient list tells you more than the front of the tin. Ingredients are listed in order by weight, and the label has to show the percentage of the key ingredient, FSANZ explains. The Stock Merchant's extra virgin olive oil tin, for example, lists 70.8% sardines, organic extra virgin olive oil and salt.
2. Whole fish or fillets
Whole tinned sardines come with skin and their soft backbone, which is cooked soft enough to eat with a fork. If that puts you off, look for the word fillets. MAR's 250g jar holds hand-cleaned fillets rather than whole fish.
Size matters too. Small sardines, sold as little sardines or xouba in Galicia, are more delicate. Larger fish are meatier and stand up better in a sauce.
3. Where and how they were caught
Look for the country of origin and anything about the fishing method. Several of The Stock Merchant's tins carry MSC certification, the blue fish label for fisheries assessed as sustainable. Good Fish and Fish4Ever say their sardines are caught by small boats, and MAR's listing names purse seine fishing in Portugal.
4. Organic, and what it covers
Sardines are wild fish, so the organic part of a tin is the oil or sauce. Fish4Ever's tomato sauce, for instance, is made with organic tomato, olive oil, onion, garlic and paprika. Check the ingredient list to see which parts are certified.
Every sardine on our shelves, compared
Origin details are taken from each maker's listing. Where a listing doesn't say, we've named the brand's home country and you'll find the rest on the tin.
| Tin or jar | Packed in | Where from |
|---|---|---|
| La Narval Sardines in Olive Oil 120g | Olive oil | Galicia, Spain |
| La Narval Sardines in Tomato 115g | Tomato sauce | Galicia, Spain |
| La Narval Spicy Sardines 115g | Spicy sunflower oil | Galicia, Spain |
| La Narval Sardines Xouba 120g | See the tin (small sardines) | La Narval, Spain |
| Pan do Mar Little Sardines 120g | Organic extra virgin olive oil | Northeast Atlantic |
| Good Fish Sardines in EVOO 120g | Organic extra virgin olive oil (35%) | Spain |
| Good Fish Sardines in EVOO 195g | Organic extra virgin olive oil (35%) | Spain and Portugal |
| The Stock Merchant Sardines in EVOO 120g | Organic extra virgin olive oil | North Atlantic |
| The Stock Merchant Spicy Sardines 120g | Organic EVOO with organic chilli | MSC-certified fishery |
| The Stock Merchant Smoky-Style Sardines 120g | Organic EVOO, natural smoke flavour | Portugal |
| The Stock Merchant Sardines in Pure Water 120g | Water with sea salt | Portugal, MSC certified |
| MAR Sardines in Brine 120g | Brine (water and salt) | Portugal |
| MAR Sardine Fillets in EVOO, jar 250g | Organic extra virgin olive oil (24%) | Portugal |
| Fish4Ever Sardines in Olive Oil & Lemon 120g | Organic EVOO and lemon | Portugal, small boats |
| Fish4Ever Sardines in Tomato Sauce 120g | Organic tomato sauce | Portugal, small boats |
| Fish4Ever Sardines in Piri Piri 120g | Organic tomato and chilli sauce | Portugal, small boats |
| Nuri Sardines in Olive Oil 125g | Olive oil | Nuri, Portugal |
| Nuri Spiced Sardines in Olive Oil 125g | Olive oil with vegetables and spices | Matosinhos, Portugal |
| Nuri Sardines in Spiced Tomato 125g | Tomato sauce with piri-piri | Matosinhos, Portugal |
The brands, in a bit more detail
La Narval
From Galicia's Ría de Arousa, made to family recipes since 1966. The olive oil tin has three ingredients, sardines, olive oil and salt, and holds six to twelve small, hand-cleaned fish. The spicy tin uses sunflower oil, and the xouba are the small ones.

The Stock Merchant
Four tins on our shelf. The extra virgin olive oil tin lists 970mg of EPA and DHA, the long-chain omega-3 fats, per 100g on its listing. There's also a spicy version with organic chilli, a smoky-style tin and a pure water tin with just a pinch of sea salt.

Good Fish
Sardines from Spain (and Portugal, for the larger size) caught by small boats, hand processed and packed in 35% certified organic extra virgin olive oil. The listing describes them as BPA free and fair trade certified. Choose the 120g tin or the larger 195g size.
MAR
Portuguese sardines, and the only fillets on this list. The 250g jar is 75% sardine fillets and 24% organic extra virgin olive oil. The brine tin is just sardines, water and salt.
Fish4Ever
Atlantic sardines caught off Portugal by small local boats and canned whole in one go, so each tin can be traced back to the catch. Three sauces: olive oil and lemon, a savoury tomato sauce and a piri piri with some heat.

Nuri
Nuri is made by Conservas Pinhais in Matosinhos, near Porto, a cannery working since 1920. Three to five sardines per tin are hand selected, steam cooked and packed by hand, and each tin is still wrapped in paper. The spiced tin adds cucumber, carrot, piri-piri, bay leaf, clove and black pepper, and there's a spiced tomato version and a plain olive oil one.
Pan do Mar
Little sardines from the Northeast Atlantic, hand-cleaned and packed in certified organic extra virgin olive oil, caught without dragging nets.
Which tin for which job
- Sardines on toast: a whole fish in extra virgin olive oil, mashed with lemon and pepper.
- Pasta: a tomato or piri piri tin, warmed through and tossed with spaghetti and parsley.
- Salads, fishcakes and first-timers: fillets, or a tin in water or brine.
- A snack board: Nuri's spiced tin or La Narval's small sardines, straight from the tin with good bread.
Storing an opened tin
Unopened tins keep in the cupboard until their best-before date. Once opened, treat the fish like fresh food: FSANZ advises moving leftovers into a clean glass or plastic container, covered, in the fridge.
Questions people ask
Can you eat the bones?
Yes. They're cooked until soft, and most people barely notice them. If you'd rather not, choose fillets.
Oil or water?
Oil gives a richer fish and a flavoured oil you can cook with. Water and brine are plainer and work best when the fish is going into something else.
Are any of these organic?
The fish is wild, so it can't be certified organic. Several brands use certified organic oil or sauce, and the ingredient list shows which.
Can you post sardines?
Yes. They're shelf stable, so they can go by Australia Post as well as in our delivery van.
Find sardines in our tinned fish range, in store at Leichhardt and Crows Nest, seven days. Stock differs between stores, so call (02) 9564 1679 to check before you make a special trip. Our refrigerated van delivers from Leichhardt, Monday to Saturday, and our delivery page explains how it works.
Written by the Unique Wholefood team. Updated November 2026.
Shipping, Delivery & Returns · Shipping Policy · Refund Policy · Terms of Service · Privacy Policy · FAQ
This article is general information only and isn't medical, dietary or nutritional advice. If you have a health condition, an allergy or intolerance, or you're making a big change to how you eat, please talk to your doctor or an Accredited Practising Dietitian first. Product details, ingredients, allergens, prices and stock are taken from the makers and our listings at the time of writing and can change, so always check the label before you buy. All our fresh fruit and veg is certified organic and Australian-grown; other products are certified organic only where the label says so. Delivery areas, prices and times can change, and the current terms are on our Shipping, Delivery & Returns page.